Russia's Arctic LNG 2 Seeks $1B Damages from Hanwha Ocean

Russia's Novatek-led Arctic LNG 2 project is seeking approximately $1 billion in damages from South Korean shipbuilder Hanwha Ocean over terminated ice-class LNG tanker orders, according to a disclosure by Hanwha. The claim was filed with the Singapore International Arbitration Centre and totals KRW 1.37 trillion, equivalent to about $1.02 billion.

Background of Dispute

The dispute arises from contracts originally signed between Arctic LNG 2 and Hanwha Ocean, which was previously known as Daewoo Shipbuilding & Marine Engineering (DSME). The project initially involved the construction of six Arc7 ice-class LNG tankers, including three for Russia’s Sovcomflot and three for Japan’s Mitsui O.S.K. Lines. However, Hanwha has previously announced that the cancellation of the orders destined for Sovcomflot was due to sanctions imposed on Russia following its actions in Ukraine.

Impact of U.S. Sanctions and Production Delays

U.S. sanctions targeting Russia have significantly impacted Arctic LNG 2's operations, leading to delays in cargo deliveries. Novatek began production at the project in December 2023 but faced further challenges that delayed the start of cargo deliveries until August 2024, all destined for China.

These complications and contract cancellations have not been confined to a single dispute: Hanwha Ocean reported an earlier claim from Arctic LNG 2 worth approximately $850 million. This ongoing litigation adds to the financial strain on both parties involved in the project.

Financial Implications for Ship Operators

The cancellation of tanker orders and subsequent legal battles have significant implications for ship operators in the LNG sector. The termination of contracts with Hanwha Ocean not only affects Arctic LNG 2 but also impacts Sovcomflot, which had ordered three Arc7 tankers.

For Sovcomflot, this situation underscores the risks associated with relying on contracts with foreign shipbuilders, especially during times of geopolitical tension. Similarly, other operators considering newbuildings or long-term charters may need to reassess their risk management strategies in light of these disputes and potential future sanctions.

What This Means for Operators

The dispute between Arctic LNG 2 and Hanwha Ocean highlights the financial and operational risks associated with high-profile, complex projects like Arctic LNG 2. For ship operators, this means conducting thorough due diligence on their partners, especially when considering long-term contracts in volatile geopolitical environments.

Moreover, the ongoing legal battles could lead to increased costs for all parties involved and potentially delay project timelines. Operators may need to be more cautious about entering into similar agreements or seek alternative solutions that mitigate these risks. The dispute also emphasizes the importance of robust risk mitigation strategies, including insurance coverage and contingency plans.

Related coverage

• Yang Ming Orders Six LNG-Powered Container Ships from Hanwha Ocean